Inevitable Accident or Wrongful Act: Judging the Titanic Disaster
Weighing the Evidence
All documents and text associated with this activity are printed below, followed by a worksheet for student responses.Introduction
On its maiden voyage in April 1912, the RMS Titanic with its 2200 passengers struck an iceberg and sank in less than 3 hours. Only 706 survived. Following the sinking, the owners of the Titanic filed a petition to limit their liability against any claims for loss of life, property and injury. Unless survivors and the families of victims could prove that the crew and the owners had caused the disaster through wrongful acts, fault or negligence, they could be entitled to no restitution.Analyze the evidence provided as a part of this case and decide whether the Titanic disaster was an inevitable accident or caused by the crew and owners of the White Star Line.
Name:
Class:
Class:
Worksheet
Inevitable Accident or Wrongful Act: Judging the Titanic Disaster
Weighing the Evidence
Examine the documents and text included in this activity. Consider how each document does or does not support two opposing interpretations or conclusions. Fill in the topic or interpretations if they are not provided. To show how the documents support the different interpretations, enter the corresponding document number into the boxes near the interpretation. Write your conclusion response in the space provided. Interpretation 1
The Titanic disaster was an inevitable accident that could not have been prevented or minimized.
The Titanic disaster was an inevitable accident that could not have been prevented or minimized.
The Titanic Disaster
Interpretation 2
The Titanic disaster was caused by the wrongful acts, fault and negligence of its crew and owners.
The Titanic disaster was caused by the wrongful acts, fault and negligence of its crew and owners.
1
Activity Element
Photograph of a Lifeboat Carrying Titanic Survivors
Page 1
2
Activity Element
Daily Memorandum from the Hydrographic Office Reporting Titanic Disaster
Page 1
3
Activity Element
List or Manifest of Alien Passengers for the United States Immigration Officer at Port of Arrival, R.M.S. CARPATHIA
Page 1
4
Activity Element
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 1
5
Activity Element
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 1
6
Activity Element
Deposition of George Rheims
Page 1
7
Activity Element
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 1
8
Activity Element
Deposition of William T. Turner
Page 1
9
Activity Element
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 1
10
Activity Element
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 7
11
Activity Element
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 4
12
Activity Element
Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
Page 1
13
Activity Element
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 1
Conclusion
Inevitable Accident or Wrongful Act: Judging the Titanic Disaster
Weighing the Evidence
Based on the evidence provided:- Do you think that the sinking of the Titanic was an inevitable accident or the result of the wrongful acts, fault and negligence of its crew and owners?
- What individual piece of evidence did you find most persuasive? Why?
Your Response
Document
Photograph of a Lifeboat Carrying Titanic Survivors
4/15/1912
After colliding with an iceberg in the North Atlantic Ocean, R.M.S. Titanic sank on April 15, 1912. The Titanic only had enough lifeboats to carry 1,178 of the 2,225 passengers and crew to safety. Here, a group of men and women, some of the 705 survivors, float to safety aboard a lifeboat.
This photograph comes from the “In the Matter of the Petition of the Oceanic Steam Navigation Company, Limited, for Limitation of its Liability as owner of the steamship TITANIC” case that began after the sinking of the Titanic. This case was initiated to limit the liability of the Oceanic Steam Navigation Company, Ltd., for loss of life and property resulting from the sinking of the Titanic on its maiden voyage. The case file contains court papers, evidence, and claims of survivors and representatives of the deceased.
This photograph comes from the “In the Matter of the Petition of the Oceanic Steam Navigation Company, Limited, for Limitation of its Liability as owner of the steamship TITANIC” case that began after the sinking of the Titanic. This case was initiated to limit the liability of the Oceanic Steam Navigation Company, Ltd., for loss of life and property resulting from the sinking of the Titanic on its maiden voyage. The case file contains court papers, evidence, and claims of survivors and representatives of the deceased.
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 278337
Full Citation: Photograph of a Lifeboat Carrying Titanic Survivors; 4/15/1912; A55-279 A55-279 A55-279 A55-279; In the Matter of the Petition of the Oceanic Steam Navigation Company, Limited, for Limitation of its Liability as owner of the steamship TITANIC; Admiralty Case Files, 1790 - 1966; Records of District Courts of the United States, ; National Archives at New York, New York, NY. [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/lifeboat-carrying-titanic-survivors, September 7, 2024]Photograph of a Lifeboat Carrying Titanic Survivors
Page 2
Document
Daily Memorandum from the Hydrographic Office Reporting Titanic Disaster
4/15/1912
This United States Hydrographic Office memorandum summarizes conditions in the North Atlantic for the first half of April 1912. Paragraph five records the Titanic’s collision with an iceberg on April 14.
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 595107
Full Citation: Daily Memorandum from the Hydrographic Office Reporting Titanic Disaster; 4/15/1912; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/daily-memorandum-from-the-hydrographic-office-reporting-titanic-disaster, September 7, 2024]Daily Memorandum from the Hydrographic Office Reporting Titanic Disaster
Page 1
Document
List or Manifest of Alien Passengers for the United States Immigration Officer at Port of Arrival, R.M.S. CARPATHIA
6/18/1912
This primary source comes from the Records of the Immigration and Naturalization Service.
National Archives Identifier: 300348
Full Citation: List or Manifest of Alien Passengers for the United States Immigration Officer at Port of Arrival, R.M.S. CARPATHIA; 6/18/1912; Records of the Immigration and Naturalization Service, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/list-or-manifest-of-alien-passengers-for-the-united-states-immigration-officer-at-port-of-arrival-rms-carpathia, September 7, 2024]List or Manifest of Alien Passengers for the United States Immigration Officer at Port of Arrival, R.M.S. CARPATHIA
Page 1
List or Manifest of Alien Passengers for the United States Immigration Officer at Port of Arrival, R.M.S. CARPATHIA
Page 2
List or Manifest of Alien Passengers for the United States Immigration Officer at Port of Arrival, R.M.S. CARPATHIA
Page 3
Document
Examination of Alfred Shiers
10/31/1913
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212857
Full Citation: Examination of Alfred Shiers; 10/31/1913; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/examination-of-alfred-shiers, September 7, 2024]Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 1
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 2
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 3
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 4
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 5
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 6
Examination of Alfred Shiers
Page 7
Document
Deposition of Edward Wilding
5/13/1914 - 5/14/1914
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212853
Full Citation: Deposition of Edward Wilding; 5/13/1914 - 5/14/1914; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/deposition-of-edward-wilding, September 7, 2024]Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 1
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 2
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 3
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 4
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 5
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 6
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 7
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 8
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 9
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 10
Deposition of Edward Wilding
Page 11
Document
Deposition of George Rheims
11/14/1913
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212861
Full Citation: Deposition of George Rheims; 11/14/1913; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/deposition-of-george-rheims, September 7, 2024]Deposition of George Rheims
Page 1
Deposition of George Rheims
Page 2
Deposition of George Rheims
Page 3
Deposition of George Rheims
Page 4
Deposition of George Rheims
Page 5
Deposition of George Rheims
Page 6
Document
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
4/6/1914
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212858
Full Citation: Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay; 4/6/1914; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/evidence-of-mr-joseph-bruce-ismay, September 7, 2024]Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 1
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 2
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 3
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 4
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 5
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 6
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 7
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 8
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 9
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 10
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 11
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 12
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 13
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 14
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 15
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 16
Document
Deposition of William T. Turner
4/30/1915
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212859
Full Citation: Deposition of William T. Turner; 4/30/1915; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/deposition-of-william-t-turner, September 7, 2024]Deposition of William T. Turner
Page 1
Deposition of William T. Turner
Page 2
Deposition of William T. Turner
Page 3
Deposition of William T. Turner
Page 4
Deposition of William T. Turner
Page 5
Document
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
10/27/1913
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212860
Full Citation: Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines; 10/27/1913; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/deposition-of-mrs-elizabeth-l-lines, September 7, 2024]Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 1
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 2
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 3
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 4
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 5
Deposition of Mrs. Elizabeth L. Lines
Page 6
Document
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
4/6/1914
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212858
Full Citation: Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay; 4/6/1914; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/evidence-of-mr-joseph-bruce-ismay, September 7, 2024]Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 1
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 2
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 3
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 4
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 5
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 6
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 7
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 8
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 9
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 10
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 11
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 12
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 13
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 14
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 15
Evidence of Mr. Joseph Bruce Ismay
Page 16
Document
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
4/3/1914
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212855
Full Citation: Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle; 4/3/1914; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/evidence-of-the-right-honorable-montgomery-alexander-carlisle, September 7, 2024]Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 1
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 2
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 3
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 4
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 5
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 6
Evidence of the Right Honorable Montgomery Alexander Carlisle
Page 7
Document
Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
6/11/1914
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212863
Full Citation: Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus; 6/11/1914; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/deposition-of-henry-l-ballantine-and-augustine-b-mcmanus, September 7, 2024]Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
Page 1
Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
Page 2
Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
Page 3
Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
Page 4
Deposition of Henry L. Ballantine and Augustine B. McManus
Page 5
Document
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
6/6/1913
This primary source comes from the Records of District Courts of the United States.
National Archives Identifier: 6212862
Full Citation: Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen; 6/6/1913; Records of District Courts of the United States, . [Online Version, https://www.docsteach.org/documents/document/deposition-of-emily-ryerson-and-grace-bowen, September 7, 2024]Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 1
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 2
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 3
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 4
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 5
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 6
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 7
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 8
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 9
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 10
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 11
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 12
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 13
Deposition of Emily Ryerson and Grace Bowen
Page 14
