• Login
  • Register
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Documents
  • Activities
  • Activity Tools
    • All Tools
    • Analyzing Documents
    • Discussion Topic
    • Compare and Contrast
    • Zoom/Crop
    • White Out / Black Out
    • Spotlight
    • Finding a Sequence
    • Making Connections
    • Mapping History
    • Seeing the Big Picture
    • Weighing the Evidence
    • Interpreting Data
  • Popular Topics
    • See All
    • National History Day
    • The Constitution
    • Sports: All-American
    • Rights in America
    • American Indians
    • Women's Rights
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • The Vietnam War
    • 1970s America
    • Congress
    • Amending America
    • Elections
    • What Americans Eat
    • Signatures
    • Nixon and Ford Years
  • Resources
    • Getting Started
    • Document Analysis
    • Activity-Creation Guide
    • Manage Assignments
    • iPad App
    • Presentation Materials
    • Webinars
      • Recorded Webinars
      • Live Webinars
MENU
DocsTeachThe online tool for teaching with documents, from the National Archives National Archives Foundation National Archives

Evaluating Perspectives on Westward Expansion

Weighing the Evidence

Print
Created by the National Archives
Bookmark this Activity in My Activities:
Copy this Activity to My Activities for editing:
Evaluating Perspectives on Westward Expansion

About this Activity

  • Created by:National Archives Education Team
  • Historical Era:The Development of the Industrial United States (1870-1900)
  • Thinking Skill:Historical Issues-Analysis & Decision-Making
  • Bloom's Taxonomy:Evaluating
  • Grade Level:High School
Start Activity
Please use a tablet or desktop computer to use this activity.
In this activity, students will use primary sources as historical evidence to determine if western expansion was worth it.
https://www.docsteach.org/activities/student/was-westward-expansion-necessary-or-were-the-consequences-too-great

Suggested Teaching Instructions

This activity can be used during a unit on westward expansion, or to explore how primary sources can provide varying perspectives on a topic. For grades 9-12. (To adapt the activity to middle school, have one group of students analyze one or two documents to present to the class and then move the documents to the scale as a full class.) Approximate time needed is 40 minutes. This activity can be done in class in small groups, or individually outside of class.

The goal is to demonstrate to students that the topic of westward expansion includes a great diversity of people, all in the west for their own reasons, with different perspectives and aspirations. Native Americans living in the west at the time were not one monolithic group, but of different tribal nations with distinct cultures. Students can't rely on stereotypes or make assumptions based on the term "Native American." Likewise, workers and new settlers in the west were not all the same—Chinese and Irish immigrants, African Americans, and native-born Americans from the east had varied experiences and motivations. The issues on which conflicts centered are not simplistically two-sided, with one faction good and the other bad, one right and one wrong. Each group and individual in every conflict was driven by unique priorities and visions. In this activity, students should grasp and grapple with such complexities.

To begin, choose one document to display to the full class and model document analysis. 

Then ask students to open the activity and to carefully analyze each document below the scale. They should evaluate each document and then move it to a position on the scale according to whether it supports the conclusion Expansion was necessary for the nation to grow and prosper, despite the negative impact on Native Americans or The impact on Native American tribes was not worth expansion, and how strongly. Remind students to not only consider whether the documents support the conclusions, but to notice other factors as well:
 
  • How relevant are the documents to the topic?
  • Are they from a credible source?
  • Whose perspective are they from?
  • Who were the intended audiences?

After they have finished moving the documents, hold a class discussion about why they placed specific documents where. Ask students:

  • Why did you place each document where you did?
  • Why do some documents carry greater weight?

Ask students to consider their personal backgrounds, as well as historical and societal impacts, and to think about the impact these might have on their interpretation. Additionally, ask them what perspectives are missing or what other kinds of documents should have been included to tell the full story. Remind them that documents can differ by creator, purpose, level of detail, and in a myriad of other ways.

Follow up with a class discussion about the strengths and weaknesses of using primary sources as historical evidence and the importance of pulling in sources from a variety of collections and repositories. Discuss the breadth of historical evidence and the challenges of coming to more complex and general conclusions—and that history doesn’t neatly fit into this or that conclusion, but is messy.

Specific discussion points could include:

  • The documents in this activity all come from the holdings of the National Archives, meaning they were either created for, or saved by, the Federal Government (or both). Will they include every perspective?
  • Every family was represented on the Hopi petition. This might add credibility. But consider too that the intended audience was the U.S. Government, and the petition could present only information that proved the distribution of land under the government’s policy would be detrimental. 
  • In considering the golden spike photo, students might discuss photography’s capacity to document reality—a critical achievement, but also point out the prevalence of staged photos in our society, even back then. They could also question the relevance of the photo: Does a photograph excluding ethnic minorities who worked on the railroad show the whole truth?

Documents in this activity

  • Hopi Petition Asking for Title to Their Lands
  • Class of boys in uniform at the Albuquerque Indian School
  • Conditions of the Indian Tribes
  • Family with Their Covered Wagon During the Great Western Migration
  • First Report of the Battle of the Little Bighorn
  • Fort Laramie Treaty
  • Golden Spike Ceremony at Promontory, Utah
  • Homestead Proof Testimony of Almanzo Wilder
  • Letter from Governor Ross Supporting Apache Removal
  • Mining Crew Drifting for Gold Below Discovery Point, Deadwood, Dak. Terr.
  • Patent for Daniel Halladay's Improvement in Windmills
  • Photograph of the entrance to the Golden Rule Mine in Tuolumne County, California
  • Poster Advertising 'Indian Territory That Garden of the World, Open for Homestead and Pre-Emption'
  • Roundup on the Sherman Ranch, Genesee, Kans. Cowboy with lasso readied looks beyond the herd on the open range to his fellow cowpunchers waiting on the horizon
  • Very early class of young boys with flags at the Albuquerque Indian School

CC0
To the extent possible under law, National Archives Education Team has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to "Evaluating Perspectives on Westward Expansion".

  • Explore Primary Source Documents
  •  
  • Discover Activities You Can Teach With
  •  
  • Create Fun & Engaging Activities
Follow us on Twitter:twitter
Follow us on Facebook:facebook
Please enter a valid email address

View our webinars:youtube

Get our iPad app:apple
New Documentsshare
New Activitiesshare

The National Archives

DocsTeach is a product of the National Archives education division. Our mission is to engage, educate, and inspire all learners to discover and explore the records of the American people preserved by the National Archives.

The National Archives and Records Administration is the nation's record keeper. We save documents and other materials created in the course of business conducted by the U.S. Federal government that are judged to have continuing value. We hold in trust for the public the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights — but also the records of ordinary citizens — at our locations around the country.
  • All Education Programs
  • Student Visits
  • Distance Learning
  • Professional Development
  • National Archives Museum
  • Presidential Libraries
  • Archives.gov
  • National Archives Foundation




Creative Commons License

Except where otherwise noted, DocsTeach is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Primary source documents included on this site generally come from the holdings of the National Archives and are in the public domain, except as noted. Teaching activities on this site have received the CC0 Public Domain Dedication; authors have waived all copyright and related rights to the extent possible under the law. See our legal and privacy page for full terms and conditions.