• Login
  • Register
  • FAQ
  • Contact Us
  • Home
  • Documents
  • Activities
  • Activity Tools
    • All Tools
    • Analyzing Documents
    • Discussion Topic
    • Compare and Contrast
    • Zoom/Crop
    • White Out / Black Out
    • Spotlight
    • Finding a Sequence
    • Making Connections
    • Mapping History
    • Seeing the Big Picture
    • Weighing the Evidence
    • Interpreting Data
  • Popular Topics
    • See All
    • National History Day
    • The Constitution
    • Sports: All-American
    • Rights in America
    • American Indians
    • Women's Rights
    • American Revolution
    • The Civil War
    • World War I
    • World War II
    • The Vietnam War
    • 1970s America
    • Congress
    • Amending America
    • Elections
    • What Americans Eat
    • Signatures
    • Nixon and Ford Years
  • Resources
    • Getting Started
    • Document Analysis
    • Activity-Creation Guide
    • Manage Assignments
    • iPad App
    • Presentation Materials
    • Webinars
      • Recorded Webinars
      • Live Webinars
MENU
DocsTeachThe online tool for teaching with documents, from the National Archives National Archives Foundation National Archives

Comparing Perspectives in the Dawes Act and a Hopi Petition

Focusing on Details: Compare and Contrast

Print
Created by the National Archives
Bookmark this Activity in My Activities:
Copy this Activity to My Activities for editing:
Comparing Perspectives in the Dawes Act and a Hopi Petition

About this Activity

  • Created by:National Archives Education Team
  • Historical Era:The Development of the Industrial United States (1870-1900)
  • Thinking Skill:Historical Analysis & Interpretation
  • Bloom's Taxonomy:Analyzing
  • Grade Level:High School
Start Activity
Please use a tablet or desktop computer to use this activity.
In this activity, students will compare and contrast two documents related to U.S. government land policies toward American Indians: one written from the view of the federal government (the Dawes Act), and the other from the Hopi Nation (a petition). They will identify the perspectives presented in the documents and consider their relationship to one another.
https://www.docsteach.org/activities/student/comparing-the-dawes-act-and-a-hopi-petition

Suggested Teaching Instructions

Use this activity while teaching about Federal Indian Policy, the history of U.S.-Native American relations, civics and government, the Bill of Rights and the First Amendment right to petition, or perspective in primary sources.

The activity can be completed individually or in small groups, and should take approximately 45 minutes, including discussion. For grades 8-12.

Begin by displaying the activity for the full class and modeling document-analysis techniques, especially if students are not used to analyzing primary sources.

Next, ask students to begin the activity, which will provide the following background information on Federal Indian Policy:
During the 19th century, the U.S. government practiced a policy of assimilation toward Native Communities, creating laws that supported this approach. For example, American Indian children were often forcibly removed from their communities and enrolled in government-run Indian boarding schools. These schools forbid students from speaking their native languages and practicing their traditional cultures, as school administrators sought to assimilate the American Indian children into mainstream "White" society. The federal government also changed how Native Communities owned land as another attempt at assimilation.
Students will be instructed to look closely at the two documents presented: the Dawes Act, or an "Act to Provide for the Allotment of Lands in Severalty to Indians on the Various Reservations," and a Hopi petition asking for title to, and tribal ownership of, their lands. Remind them to click on View Entire Document to see all pages of the documents, as well as a transcript if needed.

Students should
employ document-analysis techniques to answer the questions below the documents:

  1. Who made it? Was it a person or a group?
  2. When was it made?
  3. What information is included about who made it?
  4. Who is the intended audience?
  5. What else was happening at the time this was created? How does that context (or background information) help you understand why it was created?
  6. Why was this primary source made?
  7. Is there a "point of view" or bias? List details from the text that reveal the creator’s perspective or point of view.

When they have finished analyzing each document, students should click on "When You're Done" where they will be presented with the the following questions to consider in preparation for a class discussion:

  1. What do you think was the relationship between these two primary sources? Were they in opposition to each other? Was one a rebuttal or response to the other? [The Hopi petition asks the federal government to give the Hopi title to their lands instead of individually allotting each tribal member a plot, as had been prescribed by the Dawes Act of 1887.]
  2. Were the two different perspectives presented in the two documents in opposition? Could they have come together?
  3. These primary sources shows two perspectives on the topic of American Indian assimilation and land ownership. What other perspectives would there have been?
  4. What perspective do you bring to this topic and source? How does your background and the time in which you live affect this?

Bring the full class back together and lead a discussion on what details students noted in their comparison of the documents, and their responses to the final questions. Ask students what other types of documents could be researched to learn more. Examples could include contemporary letters, other petitions, or minutes of debates in Congress.

Documents in this activity

  • Hopi Petition Asking for Title to Their Lands
  • Dawes Act

CC0
To the extent possible under law, National Archives Education Team has waived all copyright and related or neighboring rights to "Comparing Perspectives in the Dawes Act and a Hopi Petition".

  • Explore Primary Source Documents
  •  
  • Discover Activities You Can Teach With
  •  
  • Create Fun & Engaging Activities
Follow us on Twitter:twitter
Follow us on Facebook:facebook
Please enter a valid email address

View our webinars:youtube

Get our iPad app:apple
New Documentsshare
New Activitiesshare

The National Archives

DocsTeach is a product of the National Archives education division. Our mission is to engage, educate, and inspire all learners to discover and explore the records of the American people preserved by the National Archives.

The National Archives and Records Administration is the nation's record keeper. We save documents and other materials created in the course of business conducted by the U.S. Federal government that are judged to have continuing value. We hold in trust for the public the Declaration of Independence, the Constitution, and the Bill of Rights — but also the records of ordinary citizens — at our locations around the country.
  • All Education Programs
  • Student Visits
  • Distance Learning
  • Professional Development
  • National Archives Museum
  • Presidential Libraries
  • Archives.gov
  • National Archives Foundation




Creative Commons License

Except where otherwise noted, DocsTeach is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 4.0 International License. Primary source documents included on this site generally come from the holdings of the National Archives and are in the public domain, except as noted. Teaching activities on this site have received the CC0 Public Domain Dedication; authors have waived all copyright and related rights to the extent possible under the law. See our legal and privacy page for full terms and conditions.